All organizations faced with the prospect of constructing major software systems from cots products must evaluate. Download citation a formal process for evaluating cots software products a softwareproduct evaluation process grounded in mathematics and decision. A softwareproduct evaluation process grounded in mathematics and decision theory can effectively determine product quality and suitability with less risk and at. A process for cots software product evaluation july 2004 technical report santiago comelladorda, john dean, grace lewis, edwin j. Therefore, evaluating and selecting appropriate cots product is one of the most critical activities in cotsbased system development. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to manage a cots based. Testing standard or cots systems how hard could it be.
Beyond five, you wont be able to drill down deep enough into each product. Obviously, cots components are different from custom components with respect to one or more. Sledge software engineering institute although commercial offtheshelf cots products are becoming increasingly popular, little information is available on how they affect existing software. Pdf the growing use of commercial products in large systems makes evaluation and selection of appropriate products an increasingly essential activity. Evaluating and selecting software packages that meet an organizations requirements is a difficult software engineering process. Testing cots systems evaluation testing in parallel. Often, when government looks to recompete or start a new it project, theyre presented with a commercial offtheshelf cots solution that promises to do exactly what is needed outofthebox. Defense technical information center compilation part notice. Assessment and evaluation of cots software products has become a compulsory and crucial part of any cotsbased software system lifecycle. A software product evaluation process grounded in mathematics and decision theory can effectively determine product quality and suitability with less risk and at lower cost than conventional methods.
Software evaluation guide software sustainability institute. Selection of a wrong software package can turn out to be costly and adversely affect business processes. Cots software evaluation techniques semantic scholar. A process for cots software product evaluation springerlink. Pdf a new software quality model for evaluating cots.
Boehm confirms that the usage of cots products has increased significantly in building software systems during the last decade. Keywords commercial offtheshelf, cots, software, evaluation 1 introduction in modern cots based systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. Checklist for evaluating tech tools, apps, software, and hardware. Employing commercial offtheshelf cots software products as components in largescale longlived systems has been proposed as a way to reduce both. Additionally, the requirements gathering and detailing can be conducted in a justintime jit manner over the course of the entire selection phase rather than as a big bang effort at the beginning of implementation. Evaluating commercial offtheshelf cots software methodology an agency endeavoring to implement enterprisewide erm should consider the following steps when performing a cots software evaluation to identify and assess products that will meet the requirements and perform effectively within its particular environment. A management guide to software maintenance in cotsbased. The objective is to develop a generic process for evaluating cots network software security products. Thus, the authors seek to develop a formal process for effective software product evaluation to assess commercialofftheshelf product quality and suitability before purchase. A commercial offthe shelf cots item is one that is sold, leased, or licensed to the general public. Mar 26, 2019 when looking at the components, rather than the sum of its parts, you may be more likely to reuse existing software, whether its free and open source or cots. Specifics about the quantification and application of these factors can be found in 6.
Jun 09, 2017 commercial offtheshelf cots is a term that references nondevelopmental items ndi sold in the commercial marketplace and used or obtained through government contracts. Among the most critical processes in cotsbased systems are the evaluation and selection of the cots components. From system requirements to cots evaluation criteria. Increasing demand for security commercial products requires an improvement of methods for evaluating their software quality. Mar 14, 2016 cots is the acronym for commercialofftheshelf, referring to the products that are tailored for specific purposes and as per parameters that are defined for an explicitly structured range. Sep 01, 2016 however, unlike software products that we can just install and start using right outofthebox, these cots systems must typically undergo configuration, customization andor extension before they will meet the full business needs of the enduser. In this paper, the criteria for evaluating cots software through more acceptable criteria in the applicable domain of aml are narrowed.
Analyze software requirements software requirements analysis is a critical part of the software development process, although too often this activity is over. The steps are organised into three phases prepare, conduct and report. Unfortunately, many methods that have been proposed in previous studies for evaluating and selecting cots. Apr 04, 2011 checklist for evaluating tech tools, apps, software, and hardware i have been searching high and low for an efficient, easytounderstand list of criteria for evaluating hardware, software, tools, and everything in between. A new product which has only just begun being evaluated by a few customers can not be tested with the same longterm approach as a mature product that has reached a broader market.
A formal process for evaluating cots software products ieee. A management guide to software maintenance in cotsbased systems. Keywords commercial offtheshelf, cots, software, evaluation 1 introduction in modern cotsbased systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. In the recent years, the commercial offthe shelf cots products are being increasingly used in the world of software development.
The demonstration is your best chance to answer that question for yourself. A formal process for evaluating cots software products computer. The increased use of cots software in organizations of any size makes evaluation and selection of an appropriate product an essential. At this stage requirements are generally less than completely defined and often provide only the most. A related term, mil cots, refers to cots products for use by the u. This approach will also ensure that the effort put into evaluating the candidate cots systems is minimized overall. A process for cots software product evaluation sei digital library. I have been searching high and low for an efficient, easytounderstand list of criteria for evaluating hardware, software, tools, and everything in between. These definitions show that although oss is not explicitly defined in dod guidance and directives, the terms already in place clearly fit.
Keyword software evaluation software selection evaluation criteria software selection tools 2 3. Commercial offtheshelf or commercially available offtheshelf cots products are packaged solutions which are then adapted to satisfy the needs of the purchasing organization, rather than the commissioning of custommade, or bespoke, solutions. With an abundance of cots software packages to choose from, the problem now is how to systematically evaluate, rank, and select a cots product that best. A management guide to software maintenance in cots. Courtheyna formal process for evaluating cots software products. Commercial offt heshelf cots security products evaluation. An alternative methodology is one in which the cots. By now, you should have a short list of five or fewer products. Trial and evaluation of information technology hardware. It considers the issues and risks in using cots software over the life cycle and how to control them.
A process for cots software product evaluation carnegie mellon. Check if you have access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article. Thus, the authors seek to develop a formal process for effective software product evaluation to assess commercialofftheshelf product quality. They propose a requirementsbased cots product evaluation process, rcpep, that ensures a quality outcome, then demonstrate its use in a case study of a us air force.
This 2004 report focuses on cots product evaluations conducted for the purpose of selecting products to meet a known need in a system. Our criteriabased approach is a quantitative assessment of the software in terms of sustainability, maintainability, and usability. Evaluating candidate cots packages adapted from software. Checklist for evaluating tech tools, apps, software, and. Jul 06, 2016 this is why choosing the right software, whether cots or custom, is so important. This policy applies to all postal service personnel and contracted vendors that have a business requirement to test information technology hardware e. Cots is the acronym for commercialofftheshelf, referring to the products that are tailored for specific purposes and as per parameters that are defined for an explicitly structured range. Electronic records management guidance on methodology for. Evaluation takes time, study, understanding and a holistic view of current and future needs. Forecasts had that figure rising in 1998 to around 28. The advice applies regardless of whether youre evaluating the maturity of a number of cots software products on the market, or whether you are in the actual process of identifying one cots software product and intend to buy it. How to go about evaluating software the two approaches we use are complementary. Introduction in modern cots based systems development we need to evaluate the candidate cots components at an extremely early stage in the development process. Most online articles that i found focus on selling things, or are incredibly vague or incomplete so i decided to do some brainstorming based on what i have found in my own practice.
A risk of selecting a product with unknown quality properties is no longer acceptable. Further dissemination to other navy and department of defense dod activities is encouraged. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to manage a cots based system. Existing standards offer general frameworks but more specific models which reflect the perception of experts and customers as well as the particular characteristics of this type of products are needed. Evaluating candidate cots packages adapted from software requirements, 3rd edition by joy beatty some organizations acquire and adapt purchased packaged solutions also called commercial offtheshelf, or cots, products to meet their software needs, instead of building new systems from scratch. Cots software selection process sandia national laboratories. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to. The set of rules for cots is defined by the federal acquisition regulation far. Studies show that cotsbased commercial off the shelf systems that are being built recently are exceeding 40% of the total developed software systems. With an abundance of cots software packages to choose from, the problem now is how to systematically evaluate, rank, and select a cots product. Interestingly, when the claims of cots advantages are closely examined, one finds that to a great extent these cots components consist of hardware and office products, not mission critical software 1. Our criteriabased approach is a quantitative assessment of the software in terms of. Narrowing the quality criteria for antimoney laundering.
In other words, if we talk about software, they are the software readily available for customer use without any modification. That makes sense, since your success with a new software system is dependent on your ability to quickly get uptospeed and start using the system. Cots software quality evaluation proceedings of the second. As adapted from timing the testing of cots software products, the streams of evaluation testing would focus on the following. Assessment and evaluation of cots software products has become a compulsory and crucial part of any cots based software system lifecycle. The objective of this guidebook is to provide planning information that results in costeffective strategies for maintaining commercial offtheshelf cots software products in cotsbased systems. This includes cots software, government furnished software, open source software, and software being reused from another program. A formal process for evaluating cots software products. This can inform highlevel decisions on specific areas for software improvement. Unfortunately, many methods that have been proposed in previous studies for evaluating and selecting cots software are still have.
Evaluating of cots vs emerging fully integrated platforms. Whether standardizing accounting processes, creating additional communication channels within a business or streamlining operations, chances are there are a multitude of cots products on the market that can meet a few of, or most of a businesss needs. We define a cots product as one that is focus developing new processes for cotsbased systems lisa brownsword, tricia oberndorf, and carol a. Iso 25051, isoiec 25051 software engineering software product quality requirements and evaluation square requirements for quality of commercial offtheshelf cots software product and instructions for testing, first ed international standards organization, geneva, 2006. Download citation a formal process for evaluating cots software products a software product evaluation process grounded in mathematics and decision theory can effectively determine product. Getting organized evaluate five or fewer systems set a date for each demo. Evaluating cots products for dod information systems. The decision whether to use a cots product or build a custom software product should always be based on the needs and assets of your users and current. Todays need for rapid software development has generated a great interest in employing commercialofftheshelf cots software products as a way of managing cost, developing time, and effort. This paper presents a framework for quality evaluation process of cots software products. A formal process for evaluating cots software products abstract. Cots software quality evaluation proceedings of the.
At this stage requirements are generally less than completely defined. When evaluating a cots solution to deliver your government service to the public, be upfront about asking a cots vendor to allow your users to test out the product. The growing use of commercial products in large systems makes evaluation and selection of appropriate products an increasingly essential activity. Pdf from system requirements to cots evaluation criteria. Cots software selection process ieee conference publication. Evaluating cots products for dod information systems 2 type management would make an effort to determine as precisely as possible the potential costs and benefits of a commercial solution, and to pursue a commercial strategy where feasible. A cots product is usually a computer hardware or software product tailored for specific.
This is why choosing the right software, whether cots or custom, is so important. The use of commercialofftheshelf cots items, including nondevelopmental items, can provide significant opportunities for efficiencies during system development but also can introduce certain issues that should be considered and mitigated if the program is to realize the expected benefits. At software advice, the most common question we hear from software buyers is, which software is the easiest to use. A software supplier may need to change their testing process many times during a products life cycle. Criteriabased assessment mike jackson, steve crouch and rob baxter criteriabased assessment is a quantitative assessment of the software in terms of sustainability, maintainability, and usability. It describes changes in the software maintenance process that are needed to manage a cotsbased system. A formal process for evaluating cots software products a s government agencies and businesses become more dependent on commercial offtheshelf cots software products to automate tasks, the ability to determine product quality and suitability has become increasingly important. The objective of this guidebook is to provide planning information that results in costeffective strategies for maintaining commercial offtheshelf cots software products in cots based systems. Therefore, a model that ensures quality characteristics of such systems becomes a necessity. A related term, milcots, refers to cots products for use by the u.
1213 1324 878 1107 769 399 318 1500 363 1250 943 254 1444 1163 714 740 1405 240 827 760 432 36 131 469 645 1506 688 1187 210 1360 117 35 97 674 747 383 180 961 900 1374 1497