Political scientists have created many typologies describing variations of authoritarian forms of government. Highlights coalitions are more likely when structural circumstances favor turnovers. The origins of electoral authoritarianism and democracy by. This paper appraises the state of the field on hybrid regimes by depicting the tensions and blurred boundaries of democracy and authoritarianism with adjectives. As these regimes combine democratic and authoritarian features, some scholars locate them at the page 386very center of the conceptual spectrum and as a. The empirical chapters 412 focus on the conflictive interaction between rulers and opposition parties in the central arena of struggle under electoral authoritarianism. Andreas schedler transitions from electoral authoritarianism. Presents cuttingedge, empirical research on the internal dynamics of electoral authoritarian regimes. Way 267 conclusion beyond electoral authoritarianism. Since the rise of nazi germany, it has been one of the most widely studied ideas in social science. Authoritarianism, elections, state, military, indonesia. To investigate which events diffuse and where, we combine modern spatial.
Miller forthcoming, comparative political studies abstract do autocratic institutions matter for the welfare of average citizens. In recent years scholarly attention has shifted from the study of democratization to the phenomenon of electoral authoritarianism. About the author marisa sullivan, a fellow at isw, conducts research on iraqi political and security dynamics. Unlike totalitarianism, authoritarian regimes sometimes allow limited political pluralism though, unlike in a democracy, that opposition is limited and often not legitimate. Federalism and electoral authoritarianism under putin cameron ross abstract. Despite the large literature comparing democracies and autocracies, we know little about how human development outcomes differ among autocratic types. In authoritarian regimes, elections either do not exist or are not seriously contested. Aug 27, 20 autocracies with multiparty elections have spread across the globe, but we know little about what predicts transitions to electoral authoritarianism ea. This paper looks at the special case of militaryguided electoral authoritarianism in myanmar. March 20, 20 malaysia is an electoral authoritarian regime, not a democracy by william leong, mp for selayang as political parties gear for the final stretch to the thgeneral elections, malaysians must not forget, our country is not a democracy. Rather than place regimes on a linear continuum from. Morse skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Electoral authoritarianism in putins russia dickinson scholar.
The result known in advance, elections can be held frequently. Germani analyzes the nature, conditions, and determinants of authoritarianism in the context of latin american. Today, electoral authoritarianism represents the most common form of political regime in the developing world and the one we know least about. Putin administration to build an electoral authoritarian regime. This definitive contribution to social science literature describes germans general theory of authoritarianism in modem society, and applies it to authoritarian movements and regimes likely to merge out of the social mobilization of the middle and lower classes.
Project muse the era of electoral authoritarianism. Conventionally, we tend to think that democratic elections combine procedural certainty with substantive uncertainty, while authoritarian elections combine. In these regimes, regular elections are held for national legislatures and chief executives, yet they fail to live up to democratic standards of freedom and fairness. Much has been written in recent years about electoral authoritarianism or socalled hybrid regimes levitsky and way 2002. Electoral authoritarian regimes play the game of multiparty elections 87 by holding regular elections for the chief executive and a national legisla 88 tive assembly. To fill this gap, i use multinomial logit models to simultaneously predict transitions to ea and democracy from non electoral autocracy between 1946 and 2007. Electoral authoritarianism characterises regimes that present an illusion of multiparty democracy at the local and national levels while effectively stripping elections of efficacy. Some background on kenyas political history helps makes sense of these developments and their wider significance.
Electoral authoritarianism is a complex political phenomenon embedded in normative presuppositions that underlie the idea of democratic elections. If there are real policy divides, parties are more likely to form pecs. The methodological chapters discuss issues of conceptualization and measurement in fresh and innovate ways. Schedler 2002, but this phenomenon is not new, and most authoritarian governments that hold elections are not hybrids but simply successful, well institutionalized authoritarian regimes. May 29, 2007 electoral authoritarianism characterises regimes that present an illusion of multiparty democracy at the local and national levels while effectively stripping elections of efficacy. Antiregimeuprisingsandtheemergenceofelectoral authoritarianism namkyukim. Thus, paraphrasing odonnell and schmitter, i assert that there is no transition from electoral authoritarian rule whose beginning is not the consequence direct or indirect of uncertainties about the electoral support of the regime.
Rather than place regimes on a linear continuum from authoritarianism to democracy, it highlights the multi. Yet they violate liberaldemocratic minimum standards of freedom, fairness, and integrity in so systematic and profound ways as to render elections instruments of authoritarian rule, rather then instruments of democracy. This paper deals with the general question of how to allocate resources across the set. Examining why electoral authoritarianism crumbled so easily, it looks into the historical importance of elections, the formation of the electoral authoritarian regime under military guidance, and its demise.
Electoral authoritarianism, according to andreas schedler, is defined as states under the control of a dictator who has successfully established the institutional facades of democracy, including regular multiparty elections for the chief executive, in order to conceal and reproduce harsh realities of authoritarian governance 1. Authoritarianism is not a new, untested concept in the american electorate. The logic of electoral authoritarianism 15 elections are ambivalent tools, as much for the ruling party as for the opposition parties. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. They create opportunities for distributing patronage, set tling disputes, and reinforcing the ruling coalition, but they also mobilize threats of dissidence and scission. Filling in the lacuna, this new book presents cuttingedge research on the internal dynamics of electoral authoritarian regimes. Authoritarian elections, state capacity, and performance.
Elections and democratic transition in nigeria under the. The logic of electoral authoritarianism ethiomedia. The vote, so essential to popular participation and selfgovernment, has become a critical component for a new electoral authoritarianism. Because these regimes combine democratic and authoritarian features, scholars locate them at the very center of the concep tual spectrum and as a result. Throughout its short history, federal relations in russia have been dominated by extralegal political and economic relations rather than constitutionalism and the rule of law. Autocracies with multiparty elections have spread across the globe, but we know little about what predicts transitions to electoral authoritarianism ea. The following discussion, then, explores the extent to which strong state capacity helped suharto. To some extent, suhartos takeover constituted the militarys. Kim, nam kyu, antiregime uprisings and the emergence of electoral authoritarianism 2016. Drawing partly on huntington 1991, 110 1, geddes distinguishes personalist, military, and singleparty regimes. An electoral authoritarian regime an electoral authoritarian regime is. Offices and policies why do oppositional parties form. These hybrid regimes defy straightforward classification and challengetraditional,teleologicaltheoriesofdemocratization.
Yet, electoral behaviour has been less studied in the electoral authoritarianism literature. The russian federations unique blend of constitutional. The era of electoral authoritarianism world politics. To fill this gap, i use multinomial logit models to simultaneously predict transitions to ea and democracy from nonelectoral autocracy between 1946 and 2007. Malaysia is an electoral authoritarian regime, not a. Electoral authoritarianism schedler major reference. Washington colleges goldstein series speaker on october 3 will discuss trends in the rise of electoral authoritarianism in east africa. This paperback version features an afterword that addresses the emerging danger posed by populist authoritarianism rejecting the notion that the security bureaucracy can or should be relied upon to block it. Conceptual disagreements have been at the heart of the hybrid regime literature. The era of electoral authoritarianism volume 64 issue 1 yonatan l.
Electoral authoritarianism and human development michael k. Most of the existing literature focuses on incumbents coercive and organizational capacity as well as electoral fraud in explaining authoritarian resilience see, for example, levitsky and way 2010. Yolande bouka, who studies politics, the dynamics of war, and gender and security in subsaharan africa, will visit washington college on october 3 to speak on the rise and contagion of electoral. Supporters of the union solidarity and development party take part of the rally ahead of the landmark elections on sunday on nov. They hold regular multiparty elections at the national level, yet violate liberal. Here, i combine the electoral authoritarian subtypes into one classification and spell out the defining. Jul 22, 2010 elections can also be used to disguise authoritarian rule, what andreas schedler called electoral authoritarianism. Authoritarian regimes may be either autocratic or oligarchic in nature, and may be based upon the rule of a party or the. It is essential, however, to distinguish regimes in which democratic institutions offer an important channel through which the. Authoritarianism is related to, but distinct from, dictatorship and totalitarianism. Pdf beyond electoral authoritarianism researchgate. Chapter 6 authoritarian regimes and democratic breakdown. This was demonstrated using scaling methods and indepth interviews.
Military electoral authoritarianism in egypt article pdf available in election law journal 162. Sage reference electoral authoritarianism sage knowledge. But the unleveled electoral playing field under competitive authoritarianism. Elections and democratization in authoritarian regimes. Jul 28, 2011 this paper appraises the state of the field on hybrid regimes by depicting the tensions and blurred boundaries of democracy and authoritarianism with adjectives. The cooptation of parliament, the electoral body cne, the comptrollers office and the supreme court, just to name a few, has triggered an enduring political crisis by closing down any. This is a very useful study of the ins and outs of competitive authoritarian regimes, written by top experts in their respective fields. Authoritarianism, fascism, and national populism gino. An alternative conceptualization and ordering of regimes are subsequently introduced using a configurative approach. And the common lack of programmatic parties make pecs unusual. Electoral authoritarianism in the third wave of democratization.
Challenging electoral authoritarianism in malaysia. Electoral authoritarian regimes hold regular multiparty elections for parliament and the chief executive. This paper argues that transitions to electoral authoritarianism ea follow a. Authoritarianism and the military in modern asia 6. Authoritarianism is related to ethnocentrism, rightwing extremism, conservatism, and antifeminism. Electoral mobilization and authoritarian elections. Authoritarianism is a form of government characterized by strong central power and limited political freedoms. Careful empirical analysis has shown that electoral processes initiated by authoritarian leaders near what turns out to be the end of the regime can be predicted by the threats they face, whereas holding elections during the early and middle periods of regime duration cannot wright 2006. When autocratic ruling parties accede to democratization, they do not. Notably, this conceptual map will form the basis for our argument in the proceeding section that identifies the electoral regime concept as a major source of conceptual confusion. However, the term pseudodemocracy resonates distinctively with the contemporary era, in which democracy is the only broadly legitimate regime form, and regimes have felt unprecedented pressure international and domestic to adoptor at least to mimicthe democratic form. June2016 abstract thispaperexplorestheroleofthreatsfrombelowintheemergenceofelectoral.
The spectrum of nondemocratic regimes richard snyder 292 bibliography 311 tables and figures tables 5. Sustaining and subverting electoral authoritarianism english 2015 isbn. These and other related concerns about the need for electoral reform in malaysia hastened the establishment of the bersih movement in november 2006. The key that unlocks the door to electoral authoritarian regime change is the. Electoral authoritarian regimes practice authoritarianism behind the institutional facades of representative democracy. Aug 17, 2017 the vote, so essential to popular participation and selfgovernment, has become a critical component for a new electoral authoritarianism. April 20 marisa sullivan middle east security report 10. Sep 18, 2017 washington colleges goldstein series speaker on october 3 will discuss trends in the rise of electoral authoritarianism in east africa. This process is rather similar to the situation in consolidated democracies. Federalism and electoral authoritarianism under putin. Each chapter is organized around a different aspect of these types of regimes, from various strategies of votebuying to the role of national security forces. Authoritarian regimes may be either autocratic or oligarchic in nature, and may be based upon the rule of a party or the military in an influential 1964 work.
1449 701 501 569 1495 663 1278 73 1442 1053 1430 342 1392 673 346 783 864 17 1340 853 1184 722 1261 321 341 938 998 850 990 248 819